When one needs the space of a barrel or pillow (not just the object) and shaking/tilting is insufficient, may one carry it away with the muktze on top?
Synopsis
Seif 5 extends the tilting/shaking permit: when one specifically needs the space (not just the object) and tilting/shaking is inadequate to vacate the space, one may carry the barrel or pillow together with the muktze.
More in Muktzeh Categories and Details
May a parent carry a child who is holding a stone (muktze) on Shabbat?
4 opinions
When the child holds a coin (dinar) rather than a stone, may the parent even hold the child's hand while the child walks on his own?
5 opinions
May a basket with a hole plugged by a stone be carried on Shabbat?
3 opinions
May a gourd (kiruya) used as a water bucket, with a stone tied to it for weight, be carried on Shabbat?
3 opinions
May a basket containing fruit and a stone (muktze) be carried when the fruit would be ruined if shaken out?
5 opinions across 3 eras
If one needs the space occupied by a basket (not just the basket itself) and there is muktze inside, may one carry the basket with the muktze to vacate the space?
1 opinions
If a stone was forgotten (not deliberately placed) on a barrel or money on a pillow, how may one deal with the muktze to access the permitted item?
4 opinions
If the barrel cannot be tilted in place (surrounded by other barrels), may one carry the whole barrel with the stone to another location to tilt it there?
3 opinions
Related from other topics
May one carry a vessel that has both a permitted item and a muktze item on it?
Handling Muktzeh Indirectly
Is it permitted to carry between a makom patur (exempt space) and a private or public domain?
Laws of Karmelit
What rabbinic corrective arrangement is required to permit carrying in a three-walled space open on the fourth side?
Valid Cross-Beam Materials
Is it permitted to use the space directly beneath the beam (korah) and opposite the lechi of an alleyway for carrying objects?
Alleyway Entrance Shapes
When is the small courtyard (breached into a large courtyard) permitted to carry its own indoor items into its space?
Eruv with Non-Jews in Courtyard
When soldiers of the king enter Jewish homes — whether by force or with the homeowner's consent — and the Jewish homeowner has muktzeh items stored in those rooms, do the soldiers prohibit carrying?
City Limits for Shabbat Walking
Discussion
Discussion coming soon.
The Daily Law
One question. Every opinion. Every morning.
A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.