Does a mumar who violates only rabbinically (but not a Torah prohibition) attain full non-Jew status for other halachic matters beyond eruv?
Synopsis
While the Shulchan Aruch holds that even a rabbinic-level public violator gets non-Jew eruv status, some Acharonim hold that full mumar status for other halachic purposes requires Torah-level violation.
More in Town Boundaries for Eruv Techumin
Does a Tzaddoki (Sadducee) invalidate an eruv by his presence, and can he participate in or nullify one?
5 opinions
Does a person who does not accept the concept of eruv (even if not a full Tzaddoki) invalidate an eruv by contributing to it?
1 opinions
What is the status of a Kuti (Samaritan) in relation to eruv?
2 opinions
What is the status of a Jewish apostate (mumar) to idolatry or public Shabbat desecration for eruv purposes?
7 opinions
Whether a person who violated Shabbat while believing it was permitted (mistaken about the law) is treated as a mumar
1 opinions
Which authorities hold that even a rabbinic-level public Shabbat violation suffices to create mumar status?
1 opinions
If a Jew converts (becomes a mumar) after an eruv has been set for the year, does he invalidate the eruv for subsequent Shabbatot?
4 opinions
If a mumar's home has a door opening to a non-Jewish neighborhood, can the Jews of the courtyard push him toward that entrance so he does not invalidate the eruv?
5 opinions
Related from other topics
What is the status of Yom Tov Torah readings with regard to skipped verses — are they treated like Shabbat morning or like Shabbat mincha?
Maftir Aliyah Laws
May the Torah reader skip from one section to another during the Torah reading?
Minchah and Maariv Timing
Who has the right to hand the Torah covers to the person performing gelilah — may another person purchase this privilege separately?
Aliyah Priority and Honor
When the Torah is stored in a separate building and the synagogue has two doorways, may congregants exit one doorway before the Torah exits the other?
Reading from Multiple Torah Scrolls
What is the sanctity status of a bimah (raised platform for Torah reading)?
Study Hall Sanctity
What is the status of adding Rachaman (requests for mercy) between the fourth blessing and drinking wine or between other elements?
Women and Birkat HaMazon
Discussion
Discussion coming soon.
The Daily Law
One question. Every opinion. Every morning.
A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.