If one person standing outside a domain extends their hand in and takes an object from a person standing inside, completing both uprooting and placement alone — is the outsider liable by Torah law?
Synopsis
When the outsider both removes and places the object by themselves, the outsider is fully liable by Torah law; the insider is only rabbinically forbidden.
More in Carrying in a Karmelit
If one person extends their hand across a domain boundary with an object, and a second person removes it — which person bears Torah liability?
1 opinions
When one person's hand is extended across a domain boundary and is below three tefachim from the ground — is the hand considered to be 'placed on the ground' for liability purposes?
2 opinions
Is it forbidden to hand an object to another person's hand if that hand is above ten tefachim (a makom patur)?
2 opinions
Is the person who holds the object while someone else takes it from them (the 'passive' person) guilty of assisting a transgression (lifnei iver)?
2 opinions
Related from other topics
Must every God-fearing person feel anguished and worried about the destruction of the Temple?
Rising in the Morning
Should one visualize or contemplate standing before God at all times, including in private and when lying in bed?
Rising in the Morning
For piyyutim (liturgical poems) and prayers requiring deep understanding of their meaning, can a prayer book substitute for advance mental preparation?
Answering Amen During Prayer
May one pray for a sick person in a language other than Hebrew when at the sick person's bedside versus when not present?
Kavvanah in Prayer
Does the prohibition on sitting within four cubits apply in front of the praying person with the same force as to the sides?
Not Passing Before Someone Praying
May one sit within four cubits of a praying person if one is weak or infirm?
Not Passing Before Someone Praying
Discussion
Discussion coming soon.
The Daily Law
One question. Every opinion. Every morning.
A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.