Shabbat · Orach Chaim 347

Carrying in a Karmelit

5 questions · 8 opinions

If one person extends their hand across a domain boundary with an object, and a second person removes it — which person bears Torah liability?

1 opinions

Two Persons Sharing the Act

If one person standing outside a domain extends their hand in and takes an object from a person standing inside, completing both uprooting and placement alone — is the outsider liable by Torah law?

1 opinions

One Person Completes Both Ac…

When one person's hand is extended across a domain boundary and is below three tefachim from the ground — is the hand considered to be 'placed on the ground' for liability purposes?

2 opinions

Hand Below Three Tefachim (L…

Is it forbidden to hand an object to another person's hand if that hand is above ten tefachim (a makom patur)?

2 opinions across 2 eras

Placement in Hand Above Ten …

Is the person who holds the object while someone else takes it from them (the 'passive' person) guilty of assisting a transgression (lifnei iver)?

2 opinions across 2 eras