Is an etrog whose inner flesh has dissolved (leaving outer peel and seed core intact) valid?
Synopsis
Two opinions: one validates, one invalidates when the inner flesh dissolves but the outer peel and inner core remain intact.
More in The Etrog
Is a dried-out etrog valid for the mitzvah?
2 opinions
Does a puncture through the etrog invalidate it?
2 opinions
What defines a 'through puncture' (nikuv mefulash) in an etrog?
2 opinions
Is an etrog that is split from top to bottom valid?
2 opinions
If the outer peel is removed from the etrog, is it valid?
1 opinions
Does removal of the pitma (oketz/tip stem) invalidate the etrog?
2 opinions
Does skin discoloration (chazazit/boils) on the etrog invalidate it?
2 opinions
Can an etrog invalidated by chazazit or spots be restored by peeling?
1 opinions
Related from other topics
If the inner (left) leg of a heh is perforated after writing, how much must remain for the tefillin to be valid?
Writing Tefillin
When two courtyards are one inside the other (inner opens only to outer, outer opens to alleyway), each makes its own eruv, and one resident of the outer courtyard forgets to contribute to the eruv — is the inner courtyard affected?
When Eruv Members Violate Shabbat
When a single individual lives in the inner of two nested courtyards and two (or more) residents of the outer courtyard made an eruv among themselves — does the individual in the inner courtyard restrict the outer courtyard?
When Eruv Members Violate Shabbat
In three courtyards one inside the other, each with a single individual, and many have foot traffic through the outer — do the inner individuals restrict the outer courtyard?
When Eruv Members Violate Shabbat
In three nested courtyards, if two residents in the innermost courtyard fail to make an eruv — do they restrict the middle and outer courtyards?
When Eruv Members Violate Shabbat
When two nested courtyards each made their own eruv (not joint), is the inner courtyard restricted by the outer's eruv problem and vice versa when the eruvin are fully valid?
When Eruv Members Violate Shabbat
Discussion
Discussion coming soon.
The Daily Law
One question. Every opinion. Every morning.
A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.