May one carry a key from the karmelit in front of a garden, use it to open the gate, and return it to the karmelit?
Synopsis
A garden enclosed by walls is a private domain by Torah law but treated rabbinically as a karmelit; retrieving a key from the public karmelit, using it, and returning it is permitted since both the garden and the street are treated as karmelit by the rabbis.
More in Laws of Karmelit
Is carrying from a karmelit to the public or private domain forbidden by Torah or only rabbinically?
1 opinions
Is it permitted to carry between a makom patur (exempt space) and a private or public domain?
1 opinions
If one stands in a private domain and throws or passes an object to a public domain via a makom patur, is one liable?
2 opinions
May one stand on a makom patur and pass an object from someone in a public domain to someone in a private domain?
1 opinions
Is it permitted to transfer an object between two rabbinic domains (e.g., between two karmeliots) via a makom patur?
3 opinions
What is the carrying status of a karpef (large enclosed area without a roof) larger than beit sa'atayim that was not enclosed for dwelling purposes?
1 opinions
Related from other topics
Where may one carry stones for wiping on Shabbat — only within a private domain (reshut hayachid) or also from a karmelit?
Handling Stones and Raw Materials
What qualifies as a karmelit?
Eruv and Carrying
Are holes in a karmelit considered karmelit?
Eruv and Carrying
What are the dimensional limits of a karmelit?
Eruv and Carrying
What defines a makom patur (exempt place) and does it exist within a karmelit?
Eruv and Carrying
Is the sea (or a large body of water) considered reshut ha-yachid or karmelit?
Eruv and Carrying
Discussion
Discussion coming soon.
The Daily Law
One question. Every opinion. Every morning.
A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.