Is the chovel (wounding) prohibition on Shabbat based on mefarek (extracting) or on taking a life-force?
Synopsis
The Rambam holds chovel is a toldah of dash/mefarek (extracting blood from beneath the skin). Most Rishonim hold it is based on taking the neshama (life-force) from that location.
More in Childbirth on Shabbat
What is the general status of a woman in childbirth regarding Shabbat desecration?
4 opinions
May one light a candle on Shabbat for a woman in labor, even if she is blind?
4 opinions
May one assist a non-Jewish woman in childbirth on Shabbat?
5 opinions
When does a woman attain the status of 'yoledet' for purposes of permitting Shabbat desecration?
6 opinions
What are the three time periods after childbirth regarding Shabbat desecration?
6 opinions
How are the three days counted — from birth or from onset of labor? And are they calendar days or 24-hour periods?
4 opinions
If a woman dies during labor, may one cut open her abdomen on Shabbat to extract the fetus?
5 opinions
May one make a fire (mdurah) for a post-partum woman on Shabbat, and for how long after birth?
4 opinions
Related from other topics
Does reciting a Name without Malkhut (or vice versa) violate the prohibition of taking God's Name in vain (lo tisa)?
Blessings on Trees in Bloom
When partners stipulated at the outset, and at the time of distribution the non-Jew volunteers to split equally (rather than taking more for Shabbat profits) — is this permitted?
Erev Shabbat Candle Lighting
If one lent or rented an animal to a non-Jew with a condition to return it before Shabbat, but the non-Jew delayed and Shabbat has arrived — what should the Jew do to avoid a Torah prohibition?
Shabbat Candle Materials
What is the underlying reason for the prohibition on commencing a sea voyage within three days of Shabbat?
Work Forbidden After Candle Lighting
In communities where the custom is not to begin any voyage on Erev Shabbat, does a short voyage also fall under that prohibition?
Work Forbidden After Candle Lighting
Does the prohibition on work after Minchah on Erev Shabbat apply to hired workers (po'alim) employed by another, or only to someone doing his own work?
Bathing Before Shabbat
Discussion
Discussion coming soon.
The Daily Law
One question. Every opinion. Every morning.
A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.