In the current era, when bandits come for money only, may Shabbat be violated to repel them?
Synopsis
A minority opinion (cited as 'yesh mi she'omer') holds that in contemporary times, a financial siege also permits Shabbat violation since resistance to robbery often escalates to bloodshed.
More in Rescuing from Danger on Shabbat
Is it permitted to extinguish a fire on Shabbat to prevent danger to life, and does this apply even when the threat is indirect or potential?
4 opinions
When a person is buried in an avalanche/collapse and it is unknown whether the person trapped is Jewish, do we clear the debris on Shabbat?
6 opinions across 3 eras
When there are multiple layers of doubt about whether a trapped person is alive and Jewish, do we still clear the debris on Shabbat?
3 opinions
If a person found under debris is critically injured and can only live a short time, do we still clear the debris on Shabbat?
3 opinions
If people on top of the debris are found dead, should we stop clearing or continue to check if those underneath may still be alive?
2 opinions
When non-Jews besiege a Jewish city, under what circumstances may Shabbat be violated to defend the city?
4 opinions
Is there an obligation to violate Shabbat to rescue Jews endangered at sea, in a flood, or being pursued by enemies?
3 opinions
After going out on Shabbat to rescue others, may the rescuers return to their home with their weapons?
3 opinions
Related from other topics
Must a person who depends on others for sustenance still spend money to honor Shabbat?
Honoring and Enjoying Shabbat
May a Jew give money to a non-Jew to invest/trade with, and share equally in profits even though the non-Jew may trade on Shabbat?
Erev Shabbat Candle Lighting
Is it a mitzvah (or obligation) to check one's garments on Erev Shabbat close to dark to ensure no forbidden item is in them?
Personal Grooming for Shabbat
What is the current practice to signal the approach of Shabbat in place of the ancient shofar blasts?
Opening a Pot on Shabbat
Is extinguishing a candle on Shabbat for fear of bandits or enemies permitted when life is at risk?
Extinguishing a Fire on Shabbat
Is it proper to prolong and beautify the Shabbat zemirot with melody, and may one admonish a chazzan who prolongs them?
Non-Jew Operating Equipment on Shabbat
Discussion
Discussion coming soon.
The Daily Law
One question. Every opinion. Every morning.
A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.