Is Shehecheyanu a mandatory (chova) or optional (reshut) blessing on new seasonal fruit?
Synopsis
The Gemara characterizes Shehecheyanu on new fruit as reshut (optional). Aruch HaShulchan argues that on fruit, it has been accepted as a chova. Authorities debate the practical weight of this distinction.
More in Shehecheyanu
When seeing a beloved friend after 30 days, is Shehecheyanu required?
3 opinions
Does receiving letters from a friend before seeing him affect whether Shehecheyanu or Mechayeh Meitim is recited?
3 opinions
Is Shehecheyanu over a new seasonal fruit recited upon first sight or only at the time of eating?
5 opinions
When eating a new fruit, must Shehecheyanu be recited again if one already said it on a similar but distinct variety?
3 opinions
If one already recited Shehecheyanu on grapes, must one recite it again when drinking new wine from those grapes?
2 opinions
Is Shehecheyanu recited on a fruit that does not renew seasonally, or on produce that is available year-round?
4 opinions
From which stage of ripeness may Shehecheyanu be recited on a new fruit?
3 opinions
Which types of unusual physical appearances trigger the blessing of Meshaneh HaBriot?
1 opinions
Related from other topics
When guests are invited and various fruits are brought to them one after another, must they recite a new blessing for each type of fruit?
Leaving the Table During a Meal
What blessing is recited when the wife dies in childbirth — does the father still say HaTov veHaMeitiv or switch to Shehecheyanu?
Blessing on Seasonal Fruits
Is reciting Shehecheyanu upon acquiring a new house or vessels obligatory or merely optional (reshut)?
Blessing on Seasonal Fruits
Is eruv techumin (eruv of boundaries) permitted l'chatchila only for a matter of mitzva, or also for optional (reshut) purposes?
Yom Tov Adjacent to Shabbat — Eruv Tavshilin
On the last night of Passover Yom Tov, should Shehecheyanu (the seasonal blessing) be recited in Kiddush?
Sefirat HaOmer Customs
Is the blessing Shehecheyanu recited when constructing a sukkah?
Lulav Ownership Requirements
Discussion
Discussion coming soon.
The Daily Law
One question. Every opinion. Every morning.
A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.