Can one fulfill the Hoshana Rabbah willow obligation with the willow already in the lulav?
Synopsis
One cannot fulfill the Hoshana Rabbah willow obligation with the lulav's willow, even if lifted a second time specifically for that purpose. One opinion permits it when lifted a second time with that specific intent.
More in Hoshana Rabbah
What customs are observed on Hoshana Rabbah (the seventh day of Sukkot)?
3 opinions
Is the willow beaten on Hoshana Rabbah accompanied by a blessing?
1 opinions
Should the willow on Hoshana Rabbah be circled with the lulav, the willow alone, or both?
2 opinions
What is the minimum quantity of willow required for the Hoshana Rabbah beating?
2 opinions
Is it permitted to benefit from the willow after taking it on Hoshana Rabbah?
3 opinions
Is one permitted to cut willow for Hoshana Rabbah from a non-Jew's land?
2 opinions
If Hoshana Rabbah falls on Sunday and a non-Jew cut willow on Shabbat, may it be used?
2 opinions
Related from other topics
When one erred and did not pray Shacharit, may one fulfill the obligation by praying Mincha twice?
Missed Prayers
When one erred and did not pray Mincha, may one fulfill the obligation by praying Maariv twice?
Missed Prayers
When one erred and did not pray Maariv, may one fulfill the obligation by praying Shacharit twice the next day?
Missed Prayers
If one prays the make-up prayer first and the required prayer second, has one fulfilled the obligation?
Missed Prayers
Can a prayer leader fulfill make-up prayer obligation by leading the congregation in the repetition?
Missed Prayers
Who is obligated to listen to the prayer leader's repetition of the Amidah in order to fulfill their obligation?
Repetition of Amidah
Discussion
Discussion coming soon.
The Daily Law
One question. Every opinion. Every morning.
A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.