When one gives a lulav as a gift to another to fulfill the mitzvah, must it be returned?
Synopsis
If one gives a lulav as a 'gift with intent to return' (matanah al menat lehachzir), the recipient fulfills the mitzvah but must return it. The donor cannot use it before the recipient returns it.
More in Hoshanot
By Torah law, when is the lulav taken outside the Temple?
1 opinions
Is the lulav taken on Shabbat?
2 opinions
Can one fulfill the lulav obligation on the first day with a borrowed set?
1 opinions
If multiple people jointly purchased one etrog, can they all fulfill the mitzvah with it?
2 opinions
Are women obligated in the lulav mitzvah?
1 opinions
Related from other topics
May collected money for synagogue construction be redirected to another mitzvah, and does this change once stones and beams are purchased or the synagogue is built?
Synagogue Property Use Restrictions
What conditions must be met for a listener to fulfill their blessing obligation by hearing another person's blessing?
Blessings on Special Sights
If the person making Kiddush does not taste the wine, but another person present drinks a cheekful, has the obligation been fulfilled?
Kiddush on Friday Night
If one ate half a kezayit of matza and then another half kezayit, has one fulfilled the obligation?
Maror
If one blew the shofar (or performed another mitzvah) for practice or to teach others, without intending to fulfill the personal obligation, has one fulfilled the obligation?
Proper Pronunciation of Shema
Can one fulfill the mitzvah of lulav on the first day with a borrowed lulav?
Hadas and Arava
Discussion
Discussion coming soon.
The Daily Law
One question. Every opinion. Every morning.
A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.