Is there uncertainty whether adult sons and sons-in-law who are dependents in the household require independent lulavim?
Synopsis
There is an unresolved question whether adult family members living under the father's roof and relying on his support require independent ownership or may be included under a communal arrangement, by contrast with the rules for first-day obligations.
More in Lulav During Hallel — Shaking
Is a father obligated to buy a lulav for his young son who knows how to shake it properly?
3 opinions
Is the father obligated to purchase a dedicated lulav for the child, or may he let the child use his own lulav after he uses it?
3 opinions
May children who do not yet know how to bless be taught to shake the lulav?
1 opinions
Does the child's lulav require all four species to be valid for educational purposes?
1 opinions
What is the proper definition of knowing how to shake the lulav according to the Jerusalem Talmud?
1 opinions
Is the obligation to educate a child in lulav-shaking the same as the obligation to educate in other mitzvahs?
1 opinions
Can multiple family members share one lulav, or does each require independent ownership for the obligation to be fulfilled?
1 opinions
Related from other topics
Does the requirement to complete the Amidah before Kaddish apply only in Ma'ariv (where there is no Kedushah), or also in Shacharit and Minchah?
Individual Additions to Prayer
If one is uncertain in the hot season whether one mentioned rain, and uncertainty continues throughout a 30-day period, what is the presumption?
Rain Request (V'Ten Tal U'Matar)
Is Nefilat Apayim (full face-covering) required only in a place where there is a Torah scroll, or may it be done anywhere?
Ashrei and U'Va L'Tzion
What is the minimum number of adults required for public Torah reading?
Musaf Prayer
If there is doubt whether water was used for labor, whether it has the required measure, or whether it is impure — is one considered clean, and must one use other water if available?
Who Must Wash Hands for Bread
Does the revi'it requirement apply the same way to children and adults? How is a revi'it calculated when two people each wash one hand and then one person washes the second hand?
Who Must Wash Hands for Bread
Discussion
Discussion coming soon.
The Daily Law
One question. Every opinion. Every morning.
A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.