What if the sounder exits the pit mid-sounding; do listeners outside fulfill?
Synopsis
If the sounder exits mid-sounding, outside listeners hear only the end of the sounding. They do not fulfill unless there is a minimal sounding duration after the exit.
More in Shofar Sound Requirements
What is the halakhic status of hearing shofar sounds from within a pit or cave?
3 opinions
What is the status of a barrel or sealed container for hearing shofar?
2 opinions
If one begins sounding in a pit and then exits, do they fulfill the obligation?
2 opinions
Does one fulfill the obligation when hearing only part of the sounding in an obligatory state?
2 opinions
What is the status of one sounding on behalf of another in an unintentional manner?
1 opinions
Does the sounder inside the pit fulfill while others outside hear?
2 opinions
What intent is required from the sounder to discharge outside listeners' obligation?
1 opinions
Does the listener inside the pit need to fulfill with the sounder inside or outside?
1 opinions
Discussion
Discussion coming soon.
The Daily Law
One question. Every opinion. Every morning.
A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.