If a courtyard is breached on Shabbat into the public domain (reshut harabim) or a carmelit, may residents carry within the courtyard?
Synopsis
A courtyard that had established an eruv is breached on Shabbat not into another private domain but into the public domain or carmelit. Does the huchra huchshar principle still apply?
More in Eruv with Non-Jews in Courtyard
If two courtyards established an eruv through a shared doorway or window and it was blocked on Shabbat, may they still carry between the courtyards?
3 opinions across 3 eras
If an eruv was established for a year (annual eruv) and the shared opening was blocked on a weekday — may the eruv be relied upon when the opening is later reopened on Shabbat?
3 opinions
If a person intentionally (b'mazid) blocked the shared opening between two eruv-joined courtyards, and then it was reopened — is the eruv still valid?
5 opinions
If a wall dividing two courtyards that each made their own separate eruv was breached on Shabbat, may residents continue to carry within their own courtyard?
2 opinions
If a small courtyard was breached before Shabbat in its entirety (b'milu'ah) into a large courtyard, with the breach not exceeding 10 amot, may the large courtyard carry items that originated indoors?
2 opinions
When is the small courtyard (breached into a large courtyard) permitted to carry its own indoor items into its space?
3 opinions
If a small roof (gag katan) was breached before Shabbat in its entirety into a large roof, may the large roof carry items that began Shabbat indoors (below in the house)?
4 opinions
Related from other topics
May one wear a properly valid tallit (with all four valid tzitzit) in the public domain on Shabbat, whether a small or large tallit?
When to Wear Tzitzit
Must one inspect a tallit for valid tzitzit before wearing it on Shabbat in the public domain?
When to Wear Tzitzit
If one discovers on Shabbat that the tallit is invalid while in a carmelit (semi-public area), must one remove it immediately?
When to Wear Tzitzit
May one wear an invalid tallit on Shabbat in the public domain if one is embarrassed to go without it?
When to Wear Tzitzit
Is it permitted to go out into the public domain on Friday night (Shabbat) wearing a tallit with tzitzit?
When to Wear and Bless Tzitzit
Does a public domain (reshut harabim) or private path separating two houses prevent combination for zimun?
Zimmun — Joining and Splitting Groups
Discussion
Discussion coming soon.
The Daily Law
One question. Every opinion. Every morning.
A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.