When the breach is more than 10 tefachim wide or spans the full wall width, and remnant walls (gidudim) remain at the breach site that are 10 tefachim tall but covered by water, may one draw water in the yard or bring it into the house?
Synopsis
If remnant walls 10 tefachim tall remain at the breach but are underwater, one may draw water in the yard (since the covered walls still function as partitions) but not bring it into the house unless an additional above-water partition is built.
More in Gardens and Open Spaces on Shabbat
When a stream of water (amat hamayim) passes through a yard and is 10 tefachim deep and 4 tefachim wide, may one draw water from it on Shabbat?
6 opinions
When the partition walls at the stream's entry/exit are built from the sides but not fully connected (gap left for water to flow), how large a gap is permissible?
4 opinions
Does a stream passing through a yard render the yard itself forbidden for carrying (even apart from drawing water from the stream)?
3 opinions
When a tongue (lashon) of the sea enters a yard through a breach, and the breach is less than 10 tefachim wide and not the full width of the wall, may one draw water and bring it into the house?
3 opinions
When the breach is more than 10 tefachim wide or spans the full wall, and no remnant walls (gidudim) remain at all, may one draw water in the yard?
3 opinions
If the entry/exit openings of a stream into the yard are less than 3 tefachim wide, is any partition required?
3 opinions
Must the partition walls built for the stream extend across the full width of the breach, or only enough to reduce the opening to 10 tefachim?
1 opinions
Related from other topics
May one wash hands with substances that originate from water, such as red midges (yevushin) or fish oil?
Who Must Wash Hands for Bread
How many people can wash their hands from a single revi'it of water, and what are the conditions?
Who Must Wash Hands for Bread
When eating fruit with its cooking water, does the fruit's blessing cover the water, or does the water need a separate blessing?
Blessings on Fruits
What is the blessing on pomace (grape husks/seeds) soaked in water, and does it matter if they were pressed by a beam vs. only trodden by foot?
Blessings on Vegetables
If one began Borei Pri Hagafen on beer or water, realized the error mid-bracha (toch k'dei dibbur — within a brief moment), and concluded with Shehakol — has one fulfilled the obligation?
Doubtful Blessings
Do the tops of walls enclosing a reshut ha-yachid have the status of reshut ha-yachid even if less than four tefachim wide?
Eruv and Carrying
Discussion
Discussion coming soon.
The Daily Law
One question. Every opinion. Every morning.
A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.