Does a balcony (gazuztra) protruding over water require surrounding walls before one may draw water through it on Shabbat?

ShabbatCarrying Between Domains

Synopsis

A wooden platform or structure extends from a house wall out over water (a karmelit), with a window opening from the house onto it. The question is what construction is necessary to permit drawing water up through a hole in the balcony into the house.

Early Acharonim
Late Acharonim
Lenient
Strict
Lesser cited
Major authority

Discussion

Discussion coming soon.

The Daily Law

One question. Every opinion. Every morning.

A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.