If one intended to throw four amot in reshut harabim and the object traveled eight amot, is one liable?

ShabbatCarrying & Transferring

Synopsis

Both Rambam and Rashi agree on exemption when the object exceeds the intended distance — though the Rambam's reasoning allows for liability if he explicitly stated he intended it to land wherever it wished.

Rishonim
Lenient
Strict
Lesser cited
Major authority

Discussion

Discussion coming soon.

The Daily Law

One question. Every opinion. Every morning.

A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.