If a person responded 'Baruch u'mevorakh' with the group at zimmun and then later hears the mezamen recite 'Baruch she'achalnu mishelo,' must he also answer 'Amen' at the end?
Synopsis
The Mishnah Berurah rules that even one who already responded 'Baruch u'mevorakh' with the group at the invitation stage must still answer 'Amen' at the conclusion of 'Baruch she'achalnu mishelo.'
More in After Wine and Fruits
What does a person who did not eat say when he enters while the mezamen (leader) is reciting 'Nivrak she'achalnu mishelo'?
3 opinions
What does a non-participant say when he enters while the others are already responding 'Baruch she'achalnu mishelo'?
3 opinions
Does someone who arrives after the respondents have already finished (and the mezamen has begun 'Baruch she'achalnu') still need to answer 'Amen'?
2 opinions
Does one who drank wine (but did not eat) with the group count as having participated for purposes of saying 'she'achalnu' in zimmun?
2 opinions
When zimmun is conducted with a quorum of ten, what formula does the non-participant use?
2 opinions
Does the same rule apply to a person who was present when the group finished eating but did not eat with them?
2 opinions
Is one obligated to respond 'Amen' to all blessings one hears, not only zimmun?
2 opinions
What formula does a non-participant respond with at a wedding zimmun ('birkat nisuin') when ten are present?
1 opinions
Related from other topics
May one answer 'Amen' after the blessing of Ga-al Yisrael (the cantor's Redemption blessing) before beginning the Amidah?
Shaliach Tzibbur — Prayer Leader
Should the chazan complete 'Lekom'tah Mishbach'im' and 'U've'Divrei Kodshakh Katuv' before the congregation begins responding with 'Baruch' and 'Yimloch'?
Tachanun
Should the congregation answer 'Amen' or 'May it be Your will' after the prayer leader's substitute Birkat Kohanim?
Lifting the Torah (Hagbah)
What blessing should the first person called to the Torah recite?
Torah Reading (Monday/Thursday)
When must the congregation answer 'Amen' relative to the completion of the blessing and the beginning of reading?
Haftarah
May one recite a personal prayer for sustenance (tefillat parnassah) between netilat yadayim and Hamotzi if one forgot to do so before washing?
Washing for Dipped Foods
Discussion
Discussion coming soon.
The Daily Law
One question. Every opinion. Every morning.
A new halakhic question and the full spectrum of rabbinic thought, delivered daily.