Rav Achai Gaon and Rabbenu Shmuel b. Natronai (as cited in Or Zarua)

Rishonim·both

1 opinions1 topics

Origin

Geographic origin not yet documented

Historical Context

Decisional Profile

Opinions recorded by category

Shabbat

Topic Coverage

Each square represents a topic. Darker squares indicate more opinions recorded in that topic.

Shabbat

Daily Life

Prayer

Blessings

Tzitzit & Tefillin

Pesach

Rosh Hashanah

Yom Kippur

Sukkot

Hanukkah

Purim

Holidays

Fasts & Mourning

Most often disagrees with

Rashi1x

Rulings (1)

Extinguishing Fire…

Does the reason the eruv fails (agent's negligence vs. sender's presumed intent) affect whether the Or Zarua authorities (Rav Achai Gaon, Rabbenu Shmuel b. Natronai) agree with Rashi?

They dispute Rashi's position; their view aligns with Rabbenu Yonatan — the operative reason is agen…